| Cast list |
| Bob Costas | as | Play-by-Play Announcer |
| Joe Morgan | as | Color Commentator |
| Bob Uecker | as | Color Commentator |
| Jim Gray | as | Field Reporter |
| Hannah Storm | as | Pre-game Host |
| Roberto Alomar | as | AL Starting Second Baseman - Baltimore Orioles |
| Sandy Alomar | as | AL Catcher - Cleveland Indians |
| Brady Anderson | as | Himself - AL Starting Right Fielder, Baltimore Orioles |
| Richie Ashburn | as | Ceremonial 1st Pitch |
| Jeff Bagwell | as | NL First Baseman - Houston Astros |
| Albert Belle | as | AL Starting Left Fielder - Cleveland Indians |
| Terry Bevington | as | AL Coach - Chicago White Sox |
| Dante Bichette | as | NL Starting Right Fielder - Colorado Rockies |
| Craig Biggio | as | NL Starting Second Baseman - Houston Astros |
| Wade Boggs | as | AL Starting Third Baseman - New York Yankees |
| Barry Bonds | as | Himself - NL Starting Left Fielder San Francisco Giants |
| Bob Boone | as | AL Coach - Kansas City Royals |
| Ricky Bottalico | as | NL Relief Pitcher - Philadelphia Phillies |
| Kevin Brown | as | NL Pitcher - Florida Marlins |
| Jay Buhner | as | AL Right Fielder - Seattle Mariners |
| Jim Bunning | as | Ceremonial 1st Pitch |
| Ellis Burks | as | NL Left Fielder - Colorado Rockies |
| Ken Caminiti | as | NL Third Baseman - San Diego Padres |
| Steve Carlton | as | Ceremonial 1st Pitch |
| Joe Carter | as | AL Left Fielder - Toronto Blue Jays |
| Bobby Cox | as | NL Manager - Atlanta Braves |
| Chuck Finley | as | AL Pitcher - California Angels |
| Jim Fregosi | as | Himself - NL Coach, Philadelphia Phillies |
| Travis Fryman | as | Himself - AL Third Baseman, Detroit Tigers |
| Tom Glavine | as | NL Pitcher - Atlanta Braves |
| Kelsey Grammer | as | Himself - American National Anthem Singer |
| Ken Griffey Jr. | as | AL Outfielder - Seattle Mariners |
| Mark Grudzielanek | as | Himself - NL Third Baseman, Montreal Expos |
| Tony Gwynn | as | NL Outfielder - San Diego Padres |
| Mike Hargrove | as | AL Manager - Cleveland Indians |
| Roberto Hernandez | as | AL Relief Pitcher - Chicago White Sox |
| Todd Hundley | as | NL Catcher - New York Mets |
| Lance Johnson | as | NL Starting Center Fielder - New York Mets |
| Chipper Jones | as | NL Starting Third Baseman - Atlanta Braves |
| Jason Kendall | as | NL Catcher - Pittsburgh Pirates |
| Chuck Knoblauch | as | AL Second Baseman - Minnesota Twins |
| Barry Larkin | as | NL Starting Shortstop - Cincinnati Reds |
| Tommy Lasorda | as | NL Coach - Los Angeles Dodgers |
| Al Leiter | as | NL Pitcher - Florida Marlins |
| Kenny Lofton | as | Himself - AL Starting Center Fielder, Cleveland Indians |
| Greg Maddux | as | NL Pitcher - Atlanta Braves |
| Edgar Martinez | as | Himself - AL Designated Hitter, Seattle Mariners |
| Pedro Martinez | as | NL Pitcher - Montreal Expos |
| Fred McGriff | as | NL Starting First Baseman - Atlanta Braves |
| Mark McGwire | as | Himself - AL First Baseman, Oakland Athetics |
| Sarah McLachlan | as | Canadian National Anthem Performer |
| Jose Mesa | as | AL Relief Pitcher - Cleveland Indians |
| Jeff Montgomery | as | AL Relief Pitcher - Kansas City Royals |
| Charles Nagy | as | AL Starting Pitcher - Cleveland Indians |
| Roger Pavlik | as | AL Pitcher - Texas Rangers |
| Troy Percival | as | Himself - AL Relief Pitcher, California Angels |
| Andy Pettitte | as | AL Pitcher - New York Yankees |
| Mike Piazza | as | NL Starting Catcher - Los Angeles Dodgers |
| Johnny Podres | as | NL Honorary Captain |
| Cal Ripken | as | AL Starting Shortstop - Baltimore Orioles |
| Robin Roberts | as | Ceremonial 1st Pitch |
| Alex Rodríguez | as | AL Shortstop - Seattle Mariners |
| Henry Rodriguez | as | Himself - NL Left Fielder, Montreal Expos |
| Ivan Rodriguez | as | AL Starting Catcher - Texas Rangers |
| Mike Schmidt | as | Ceremonial 1st Pitch |
| Gary Sheffield | as | NL Right Fielder - Florida Marlins |
| Ozzie Smith | as | NL Shortstop - St. Louis Cardinals |
| John Smoltz | as | NL Starting Pitcher - Atlanta Braves |
| Frank Thomas | as | AL First Baseman - Chicago White Sox |
| Steve Trachsel | as | NL Pitcher - Chicago Cubs |
| Greg Vaughn | as | AL Outfielder - Milwaukee Brewers |
| Mo Vaughn | as | AL Starting First Baseman - Boston Red Sox |
| Earl Weaver | as | AL Honorary Captain |
| John Wetteland | as | AL Relief Pitcher - New York Yankees |
| Matt Williams | as | Himself - NL Third Baseman, San Francisco Giants |
| Dan Wilson | as | AL Catcher - Seattle Mariners |
| Mark Wohlers | as | NL Relief Pitcher - Atlanta Braves |
| Todd Worrell | as | NL Pitcher - Los Angeles Dodgers |
| Eric Young | as | Himself - NL Second Baseman, Colorado Rockies |
