| Cast list |
| Billy Bush | as | Himself - Host |
| Nancy O'Dell | as | Herself - Hostess |
| Shandi Finnessey | as | Miss USA 2004 |
| Chelsea Cooley | as | Herself - Miss North Carolina USA / Miss USA 2005 |
| Brittany Hogan | as | Miss California USA (1st Runner Up) |
| Kristen Johnson | as | Miss Kentucky USA (2nd Runner Up) |
| Jill Gulseth | as | Miss Illinois USA (3rd Runner Up) |
| Melissa Witek | as | Miss Florida USA (4th Runner Up) |
| Marina Harrison | as | Miss Maryland USA (Top 10) |
| Jennifer Adcock | as | Miss Mississippi USA (Top 10) |
| Megan Jarensky | as | Miss New York USA (Top 10) |
| Lacie Scott | as | Miss Oklahoma USA (Top 10) |
| Brenda Kaye Brabham | as | Miss Pennsylvania USA (Top 10) |
| Jessica Furrer | as | Miss Arkansas USA (Top 15) |
| Crystal Hayes | as | Miss Michigan USA (Top 15) |
