| Cast list |
| Fred Allen | as | Sam 'Slick' Brown (The Ransom of Red Chief) |
| Anne Baxter | as | Joanna Goodwin (The Last Leaf) |
| Jeanne Crain | as | Della (The Gift of the Magi) |
| Farley Granger | as | Jim (The Gift of the Magi) |
| Charles Laughton | as | Soapy (The Cop and the Anthem) |
| Oscar Levant | as | Bill Peoria (The Ransom of Red Chief) |
| Marilyn Monroe | as | Streetwalker (The Cop and the Anthem) |
| Jean Peters | as | Susan Goodwin (The Last Leaf) |
| Gregory Ratoff | as | Behrman (The Last Leaf) |
| Dale Robertson | as | Barney Woods (The Clarion Call) |
| David Wayne | as | Horace (The Cop and the Anthem) |
| Richard Widmark | as | Johnny Kernan (The Clarion Call) |
| Joyce Mackenzie | as | Hazel |
| Lee Aaker | as | J. B. Dorset aka Red Chief (The Ransom of Red Chief) |
| Richard Rober | as | Chief of Detectives (The Clarion Call) |
