| Cast list | | John Dye | as | Bill Morgan | | Kathy Ireland | as | Kristen Klaus | | Mary Donnelly-Haskell | as | Rudolfa Klaus (as Mary Donnelly Haskell) | | Liz Torres | as | The Tooth Fairy | | Robin Avery | as | Sandman | | Penny Blake | as | Elf #1 | | Rachelle Carson | as | Harley Jones | | Douglas Campbell | as | Santa Claus | | André Carthen | as | Principal Marsh | | Michael Gilden | as | Dunder | | James Kirk | as | Kyle Morgan | | Grant Linneberg | as | Coach Zane | | Elizabeth Prout | as | Mrs. Morgan | | Jennifer Prout | as | Young Brittany | | Kirsten Prout | as | Brittany Morgan |
| | Crew list: | | Tibor Takács (Director) | | Steven H. Berman (Writer) |
|
