| Cast list | | Matt Walsh | as | Sheriff Terry Moran | | Amy Poehler | as | Doreen Moran | | Matt Besser | as | | | Ian Roberts | as | | | Nicole Abramson | as | | | Jeff Ahern | as | Copy Clerk | | Renee Albert | as | Reading Circle #2 | | Josh Belson | as | Lumberjack #1 | | Lisa Marie Bolick | as | Townsperson | | John Ross Bowie | as | Priest | | Karis Campbell | as | Jeans Woman | | Jessica Chaffin | as | | | Bill Chott | as | Ice Cream Manager | | Jackie Clarke | as | | | Shulie Cowen | as | Woman in Ice Cream Parlor | | Andrew Daly | as | Fred | | Rob Delaney | as | Whipped Cream Ass Man | | Jamie Denbo | as | Wet T-shirt Girl | | Ben Dickerson | as | Chugger #1 | | Kevin P. Farley | as | Landlord | | Kate Flannery | as | Reading Circle #4 | | Lauren Flans | as | Porn Girl | | Rob Gaughan | as | Chugger #2 | | Guy Hadley | as | Mayor Norkiss | | Rob Huebel | as | | | Eric Kirchberger | as | Eric | | Laura Krafft | as | Reading Circle #1 | | Melinda Kramer | as | Ice Cream Parlor Patron | | Vanessa Langlo | as | Harrassed Girl | | Carri Levinson | as | Monica | | Bill Lippincott | as | Ice Cream Parlor Guy | | Madeline Long | as | Stevie's Mom | | Scott McShane | as | Porn Star | | Daniel Noah | as | Reporter #2 | | Brettney Perr | as | Beach Goer / Towns Person (as Brettney Williams) | | Linda Pine | as | Harassed Girl #2 | | Rob Riggle | as | | | Jennifer Ruper | as | Townsperson | | Dee Ryan | as | Bartender | | Danielle Schneider | as | Ex-Girlfriend | | Carl Schuster | as | Nude Raver #2 | | Steve Sobel | as | Frat Guy #1 | | Yoni Tabac | as | Angry Bar Patron | | Paul Vato | as | Cubano | | Devin Westberg | as | Angry Bar Patron |
| | Crew list: | | John Ennis (Director) | | Matt Besser (Writer) | | Amy Poehler (Writer) |
|
