| Cast list | | Sam Bottoms | as | Father Michael McCarren | | Renée Coleman | as | September Lane | | Ed Binns | as | Monsignor Frank Barrett (as Edward Binns) | | Dick Cavett | as | Himself | | Page Hannah | as | Annie | | Don Harvey | as | Nathan | | Robert Lansing | as | C.A. Thomas | | Holt McCallany | as | Jay | | John Perkins | as | Cardinal Gurney | | Carol Surface | as | Swim Coach | | Tom Nowicki | as | Basketball Player #1 | | Phil Moore | as | Basketball Player #2 | | Robert Jacoby | as | Basketball Player #3 | | Jill Miller | as | Bookstore Clerk | | Virginia Light | as | Ice Cream Lady |
| | Crew list: | | William Olsen (Director) | | Hugh Parks (Writer) | | Joe Tankersley (Writer) |
|
