| Cast list | | Laura Prepon | as | Karla Homolka | | Misha Collins | as | Paul Bernardo | | Patrick Bauchau | as | Dr. Arnold | | Emilie Jacobs | as | Debbie | | Alex Boyd | as | Nick | | Carole Ita White | as | Waitress | | Fiona Manners | as | Rape Victim #1 | | Shawn Hoffman | as | Detective Steve Kirby | | Adam Lieberman | as | Detective Morgan | | Cherilyn Hayres | as | Tammy Homolka | | William Duffy | as | Detective Porter | | Tanya Lemelle | as | Rape Victim #2 | | Tony Shawkat | as | Border Guard #1 | | Kristen Honey | as | Tina McCarthy (as Kristen Swieconek) | | Cole James | as | Tina's Friend |
| | Crew list: | | Joel Bender (Director) | | Joel Bender (Writer) | | Manette Beth Rosen (Writer) |
|
